March 8, 2019
Nothing is more likely to get a senior citizen out of the house for a walk and some fresh air than attending to the needs of his or her dog (and best friend). What’s more, taking Rover for a ramble offers an opportunity to socialize with nearby neighbors and pet owners, especially if the weather is good.
So it seems to be a win-win situation on both sides of the leash. Or is it?
While walking a dog provides older Americans with a valuable outlet for regular, physical activity, findings of a Penn Medicine study indicate that fractures related to these walks more than doubled between 2004 and 2017 in patients 65 and older.
The study — published on March 6 in JAMA Surgery—established that, in this population, 78% of the fractures occurred in women, with hip and upper extremity breaks being the most common.
“Dog walking, which has repeatedly demonstrated social, emotional and physical health benefits, is a popular and frequently recommended activity for many older Americans seeking new ways to stay active,” said the study’s lead author Kevin Pirruccio, a second-year medical student in the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania. “This study highlights that while there are undoubtedly pros to dog walking, patients’ risks for falls must be factored into lifestyle recommendations in an effort to minimize such injuries.”
The study team, which included senior author Jaimo Ahn, an associate professor of Orthopaedic Surgery, and Yeo Myoung Yoon, a research assistant at Penn, reviewed all fractures in the 65-and-older population related to “pet products” in the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System database of the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission. The entries the team found— stretching across roughly 100 participating hospitals’ emergency departments—corresponded to 32,624 cases in the United States, overall.
Fracture injuries linked to walking leashed dogs were found to have increased significantly from 1,671 cases in 2004 to 4,396 in 2017—a 163% increase. About half of the injuries were related to people’s upper extremities; fractures of the wrist, upper arm, finger and shoulder were the most common in that category.
Specifically, seniors fractured their hip most often, accounting for 17% of the injuries in the database. This is particularly concerning as mortality rates related to hip fractures in the in patients over 65 are close to 30%. Why hip injuries among older people can be so deadly has to do with the possibility of setting off a domino-effect of factors that relate to poorer health, such as a sudden lack of mobility and activity.
While the numbers are sobering, the researchers believe that their count of dog walking injuries may actually be low. The study only examined reported fractures and those who went to an emergency room. Debilitating tendon or muscle damage and those who may refuse or seek out other avenues of care were not included in the study.
The researchers don’t want to keep seniors from walking dogs or owning them. But they hope their study and others that build off of it provide grounds for deeper considerations about the risks everyone faces as they grow older.
Research contact: Francis.Otto@pennmedicine.upenn.edu